Showing posts with label inventions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label inventions. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 05, 2017

Patents, schools, and false equivalency

I posted the following two comments to "Lost Einsteins, the Innovations We Are Missing", David Leonhardt, New York Times, 2017-12-03.

One could also make a correlation between innovation and the type of industries in the area.

The Minneapolis-St. Paul area once drew a lot of people to work in the computer industry.  I was one of them.  Then the medical device industry drew a lot of people.

Rochester MN has been drawing medical talent for generations.  It also once had a large IBM facility.

I wonder what all the patents in NW Minnesota were for.  Snowmobiles, fishing gear?

And then there is politics.  Do the local governments make their places nice places to live, and so many people move there?







Follow-up comment

Well, I looked up several facts about Roseau County, MN, way up north on the Canadian border.  It was where Polaris snowmobiles were invented.  For more seehttp://www.polaris.com/en-us/company.

The Census 2016 estimate of Roseau’s population is 15,629 with 18% of school age 2813 students.  So, it would be quite “easy” for Polaris to have three patents.

The research triangle of North Carolina is another high patent area.  The triangle is University of North Carolina, North Carolina State University, and Duke University, all well-known research universities.

I think a more interesting correlation would be how much people were open to new ideas.  I think the willingness to do something different would have a better correlation than number of children.

Tuesday, August 20, 2013

Intergenerational payments are not a zero sum game

Many complain that Social Security is taking from the young to pay for the old.  That is, this transfer is a zero sum game where the winnings of one are equal to the losses of others.

But consider that we play another zero sum game.  Think about those who complain about paying for schools because they don't have children or grandchildren in school.

Now if the older people are paying taxes to support public schools and the younger people are paying taxes for seniors' Social Security payments, isn't the combined system a win-win situation?

And there is more to support this win-win situation.

If older people don't pay for children's education where are the doctors going to come from?  Police and fire?  Government?  Inventors of devices and medicines to prolong life?  Sports figures to entertain?

If younger people don't pay for older peoples' retirement and health, might the older people stay working longer, leaving fewer jobs for younger people?

And the list goes on.  Older people paid for the infra-structure that younger people use today.  Would we have highways, communication systems, buildings, and much else that was paid for in full by people now dead?