Rod Grams and Jim Oberstar, candidates for the Minnesota 8th District Congressional seat, have been pointing fingers at each other about job creation or loss. Grams thinks that Oberstar is responsible for the loss of mining and forestry jobs. Oberstar is proud that his efforts created 100 jobs here and 400 there. They both cite projects they support that will create jobs.
First, is it the business of Congress to create local jobs? Isn't that something best left to the states and other local governments? Even then, by creating specific projects, other than for projects with a public use, like transit, isn't government favoring a specific interest over other interests.
Second, how much can one Representative influence a whole industry, either favorably or unfavorably. Can a Representative put ore back in the ground after a mine is worked out? Can a Representative restore resources which have been taken off the market? Can a Representative create a market for a product that has been replaced by other products? Can a Representative mitigate the effects of automation on reducing the number of employees needed?
Some of the Mesabi Range deposits have been worked out. An act of Congress won't put the ore back. Some deposits are of lower quality than deposits elsewhere. Can Congress mandate that those deposits will be worked even if the company will lose money.
Forestry jobs are down for two reasons. One is that forest land has been taken out of production because the paper companies can make more money selling their land than harvesting the trees. The land is being sold for development, often for private recreational use. Many of the new landowners have no interest in seeing their land clearcut. Two, huge amounts of paper are being recycled, reducing the need to cut more trees. There is such a glut that landfill operators use newsprint to cover the day's take of trash.
Many things that used to be built with steel are now made with aluminum or plastic. Shall Congress mandate that more steel be used in automobiles, thereby increasing fuel consumption?
Productivity increases are generally regarded as a good thing, but productivity means fewer jobs. Huge electric shovels can quickly fill a huge truck with a third of the production of a single deep mine? Shall Congress mandate that more ore be mined with pick and shovel, and possibly with more death and injury?
What Congress and other governments can do is create a climate for entrepeneurship? That includes changing expectations from finding jobs to looking for opportunities, making it relatively simple to create most businesses without a horde of lawyers, and by not favoring some businesses which will take resources or opportunities from other businesses.
Tuesday, October 31, 2006
Some complex things are simple, sort of
For the seven years we've owned our house, we've had a bedroom blind that didn't close completely. No, nobody could see in, but it still bothered us. I tried fixing it, but I couldn't figure out how to get the cords undone and reset. And we really didn't want to pay someone else to do it.
Several weeks ago I saw a display of blinds in a hardware store. The store would cut the blinds to the needed length. I went home and measured the current blind and the window frame it was covering. Then did nothing more, partly because I didn't want to carry a six-foot package on the bus.
Last week we had a series of errands that we would be doing with the car. Before leaving, we took all the width measurements for the window, including that for each of the two windows in the set.
As I looked for help in the hardware store, my wife discovered much shorter blinds that would fit the individual windows without cutting.
Yesterday was the day to install the new blinds. I gathered all the tools I thought I would need and opened a package. The directions were straightforward and I could see how everything would work. The blinds would fit in the window without problem, neither too big nor too small. Note that we intended to mount in the window frame rather than on the outside. That is, we would mount them inside the box that the window fits in.
I picked up a mounting screw and looked for a drill bit in the bunch of old bits I had in the house. None were small enough! I looked again and I looked in the tool box in the truck. The best I could find was a small box nail.
I mounted the nail in the drill, but as I suspected, the drill was almost too big to drill the topmost hole. I would have to go in at a slant. Now I knew why whoever installed other insert blinds had used only one screw.
I did succeed in getting the brackets mounted, but I had to use the smallest screwdriver to do it. The handles of the others were to big to get a decent grip in the small space.
I slid the blinds in the brackets, put the covers on the brackets, and mounted the valences without much fuss. We did crease a couple of valences, but we probably won't notice most of the time.
Wow, what a difference! The two smaller blinds make the room seem much bigger and open than the one huge blind did. And with less light coming in, we may get a few more minutes sleep in the morning.
Several weeks ago I saw a display of blinds in a hardware store. The store would cut the blinds to the needed length. I went home and measured the current blind and the window frame it was covering. Then did nothing more, partly because I didn't want to carry a six-foot package on the bus.
Last week we had a series of errands that we would be doing with the car. Before leaving, we took all the width measurements for the window, including that for each of the two windows in the set.
As I looked for help in the hardware store, my wife discovered much shorter blinds that would fit the individual windows without cutting.
Yesterday was the day to install the new blinds. I gathered all the tools I thought I would need and opened a package. The directions were straightforward and I could see how everything would work. The blinds would fit in the window without problem, neither too big nor too small. Note that we intended to mount in the window frame rather than on the outside. That is, we would mount them inside the box that the window fits in.
I picked up a mounting screw and looked for a drill bit in the bunch of old bits I had in the house. None were small enough! I looked again and I looked in the tool box in the truck. The best I could find was a small box nail.
I mounted the nail in the drill, but as I suspected, the drill was almost too big to drill the topmost hole. I would have to go in at a slant. Now I knew why whoever installed other insert blinds had used only one screw.
I did succeed in getting the brackets mounted, but I had to use the smallest screwdriver to do it. The handles of the others were to big to get a decent grip in the small space.
I slid the blinds in the brackets, put the covers on the brackets, and mounted the valences without much fuss. We did crease a couple of valences, but we probably won't notice most of the time.
Wow, what a difference! The two smaller blinds make the room seem much bigger and open than the one huge blind did. And with less light coming in, we may get a few more minutes sleep in the morning.
Saturday, October 28, 2006
Terrorists there are stopped by an army?
"We're fighting the terrorists there so we don't have to fight them here." This sounds eerily like the "domino theory"; we had to contain the Communists in Viet Nam or else we would be fighting them on our shores.
But terrorists will not be contained by an army - people in London and Madrid found that out the hard way. If there is a current terrorist plot against the U.S., it won't necessarily be planned in Iraq or Afghanistan. Why run the risk of disruption? Let's see, it could be planned in Pakistan, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Germany. Germany? Yes, Germany, remember some of the 9/11 attackers were in a cell in Hamburg.
But terrorists will not be contained by an army - people in London and Madrid found that out the hard way. If there is a current terrorist plot against the U.S., it won't necessarily be planned in Iraq or Afghanistan. Why run the risk of disruption? Let's see, it could be planned in Pakistan, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Germany. Germany? Yes, Germany, remember some of the 9/11 attackers were in a cell in Hamburg.
If God said...
Michele Bachmann, candidate for the Minnesota 6th Congressional District seat, said that God told her to run for Congress. If God told her to run, why didn't God tell her opponents, Patty Wetterling and John Binkowski not to run?
Harry Welty leads in 8th District Poll
Harry Welty, the independent candidate for the 8th Congressional District, leads in a radio station's online poll. KDAL-FM has a poll on its homepage. The choices are Jim Oberstar (DFL), Rod Grams (GOP), and Harry Welty. The results as of a few minutes ago out of 243 votes were
I would say that there are a lot of dissatisfied voters who don't like the two candidates that get all newspaper coverage.
Oberstar 11.11%Considering that most polls actually talk to between 750 and 1000 people, this is a rather outstanding result, even for self-selected voters.
Grams 7.00%
Welty 81.89%
I would say that there are a lot of dissatisfied voters who don't like the two candidates that get all newspaper coverage.
Friday, October 27, 2006
Making news or reporting news
If you search for Welty on the Star Tribune's web site, you will find two recent stories: one on shingles ("a welty rash") and one on Eudora Welty, the late writer. This from a newspaper that boasts in one of its blogs that its political home page "includes the latest profiles of candidates, their stand on the issues, fresh news, a good list of political blogs of all perspectives and other links."
Harry Welty is on the ballot for Minnesota's Eighth Congressional District, has appeared on Twin Cities Public Television's Almanac debate for this seat, and is mentioned several times on Minnesota's Public Radio site. But nada for the Star Tribune and nada for the St. Paul Pioneer Press.
The Duluth News Tribune did invite Harry to submit an essay and published it on October 20. But they would not include him in a debate on local public television. He was not a major-party candidate.
I think newspapers and other media are doing two things that are not in the public's interest. One, by excluding candidates from coverage, they are making news rather than reporting news. Two, their requirements for major-party affiliation are a self-fulfilling prophecy. "How do you get coverage of a political campaign?" "Be with a major party." "How do you get major-party status?" "Get news coverage."
Harry Welty is on the ballot for Minnesota's Eighth Congressional District, has appeared on Twin Cities Public Television's Almanac debate for this seat, and is mentioned several times on Minnesota's Public Radio site. But nada for the Star Tribune and nada for the St. Paul Pioneer Press.
The Duluth News Tribune did invite Harry to submit an essay and published it on October 20. But they would not include him in a debate on local public television. He was not a major-party candidate.
I think newspapers and other media are doing two things that are not in the public's interest. One, by excluding candidates from coverage, they are making news rather than reporting news. Two, their requirements for major-party affiliation are a self-fulfilling prophecy. "How do you get coverage of a political campaign?" "Be with a major party." "How do you get major-party status?" "Get news coverage."
Thursday, October 26, 2006
History repeats and nobody learns
Last night I read "Islam in Afghanistan" by William T. Vollman in Inside Islam. He wrote how Muslims from many countries went to Afghanistan to oust the infidel invaders, the Soviets. Interestingly, for its grander games, the U.S. funded and supplied these fighters, calling them "Freedom Fighters" even though they used terrorist tactics.
Now in addition to insurgents in Iraq who do not want foreign invaders, Muslims from other countries are pouring in to defend a Muslim country from infidels.
Not only do many of the U.S. policy makers not understand the culture of Islam, but they do not see the repeated lessons of history. Have they forgotten about the Crusades, which supposedly were to push the Muslims out of the Christian holy places?
Now in addition to insurgents in Iraq who do not want foreign invaders, Muslims from other countries are pouring in to defend a Muslim country from infidels.
Not only do many of the U.S. policy makers not understand the culture of Islam, but they do not see the repeated lessons of history. Have they forgotten about the Crusades, which supposedly were to push the Muslims out of the Christian holy places?
Wednesday, October 25, 2006
Simple living is not always simple
One of the ideas of simple living is to heat with wood rather than oil, gas, or electricity. The latter "commercial fuels" are actually simpler for daily life.
You set a dial to the desired heat level and the furnace takes care of the rest. Gas and electricity are delivered to your home on an as needed basis. The oil company watches the weather and notes your past usage. When they think you have used up over half your tank, they deliver more and leave you a bill. Except for the cost, could anything be simpler?
As the price of fuel goes up, wood becomes more and more tempting. To use wood you have to have a proper stove or fireplace. An antique wood stove won't do in a modern house. They are inefficient and can be dangerous. The best thing is to have a sealed unit in which all gases go up the chimney and not into a room. These can be pricey. Expect to pay $6,000 for purchase and installation, including any necessary chimney work.
You could purchase wood and might save compared to the other energy sources. If you purchase wood, you need to find a reliable dealer who delivers the promised wood in the promised quantity at the promised price. And you thought buying an auto was tricky.
If you own a rural property with lots of trees, you might save over commercially bought wood. On the other hand you will be doing much more work at a decrease in your personal safety. Just one small act of carelessness can bring a tree crashing down on you or a chainsaw sawing you. You also have to plan well. For next year's wood you have to cut this winter to let it dry properly. Waiting until summer or fall will give you lots of green wood.
You can do like we have to do this year, rely on already dead trees. The problem is that the dead trees may already started to rot, making starting fires even more difficult.
Remember about the automatic nature of oil or gas. A wood fire is not automatic. First you have to lay the wood just so to ignite it. Then you have to adjust the damper or air intake as the stove heats up; this is to maximize the heat that goes into the room instead of up the chimney. Then you have to periodically adjust the wood to keep it close enough to burn well or add more wood. Oops. I have to check our fireplace now.
Well, I didn't add any wood but I pulled out the air intake. The fan hadn't come on because most of the heat was going up the chimney.
Unless you build very big fires and use lots of wood, don't expect a toasty house. With two small logs, the temperature five feet from our fireplace is 64 degrees (18 centigrade). We have a three-bedroom, two-story plus basement house. We wear lots of layers.
Expect to add 1/2 to one hour of chores to your daily routine. Besides bringing in the wood and tending to the fire, you will need to empty ashes, clean the debris on the floor, and clean the glass door.
I don't know if we are saving a lot of money or not, but I think of it as doing our part to "starve a terrorist". Our oil furnace rarely comes on during the day. I don't know how well we'll do when it is below freezing all day.
References:
"How to buy firewood", Minnesota Dept. of Commerce, accessed Oct. 25, 2006
"Firewood sales heating up", Minnesota Public Radio, Oct. 4, 2005, accessed Oct. 25, 2006
You set a dial to the desired heat level and the furnace takes care of the rest. Gas and electricity are delivered to your home on an as needed basis. The oil company watches the weather and notes your past usage. When they think you have used up over half your tank, they deliver more and leave you a bill. Except for the cost, could anything be simpler?
As the price of fuel goes up, wood becomes more and more tempting. To use wood you have to have a proper stove or fireplace. An antique wood stove won't do in a modern house. They are inefficient and can be dangerous. The best thing is to have a sealed unit in which all gases go up the chimney and not into a room. These can be pricey. Expect to pay $6,000 for purchase and installation, including any necessary chimney work.
You could purchase wood and might save compared to the other energy sources. If you purchase wood, you need to find a reliable dealer who delivers the promised wood in the promised quantity at the promised price. And you thought buying an auto was tricky.
If you own a rural property with lots of trees, you might save over commercially bought wood. On the other hand you will be doing much more work at a decrease in your personal safety. Just one small act of carelessness can bring a tree crashing down on you or a chainsaw sawing you. You also have to plan well. For next year's wood you have to cut this winter to let it dry properly. Waiting until summer or fall will give you lots of green wood.
You can do like we have to do this year, rely on already dead trees. The problem is that the dead trees may already started to rot, making starting fires even more difficult.
Remember about the automatic nature of oil or gas. A wood fire is not automatic. First you have to lay the wood just so to ignite it. Then you have to adjust the damper or air intake as the stove heats up; this is to maximize the heat that goes into the room instead of up the chimney. Then you have to periodically adjust the wood to keep it close enough to burn well or add more wood. Oops. I have to check our fireplace now.
Well, I didn't add any wood but I pulled out the air intake. The fan hadn't come on because most of the heat was going up the chimney.
Unless you build very big fires and use lots of wood, don't expect a toasty house. With two small logs, the temperature five feet from our fireplace is 64 degrees (18 centigrade). We have a three-bedroom, two-story plus basement house. We wear lots of layers.
Expect to add 1/2 to one hour of chores to your daily routine. Besides bringing in the wood and tending to the fire, you will need to empty ashes, clean the debris on the floor, and clean the glass door.
I don't know if we are saving a lot of money or not, but I think of it as doing our part to "starve a terrorist". Our oil furnace rarely comes on during the day. I don't know how well we'll do when it is below freezing all day.
References:
"How to buy firewood", Minnesota Dept. of Commerce, accessed Oct. 25, 2006
"Firewood sales heating up", Minnesota Public Radio, Oct. 4, 2005, accessed Oct. 25, 2006
Sunday, October 22, 2006
Where have all the Iron Range jobs gone?
In the Grams-Oberstar debates, one of the arguments is the loss of jobs on the Iron Range. Most of the blame seems that a U.S. Representative should be held responsible for this loss. However, there are technical and economic reasons for a smaller work force.
The biggest technical reason is productivity. One has only to go to the Tower-Soudan mine and compare it to modern open pit mining. The Tower-Soudan mine employed 475 men working three shifts with picks, shovels, and explosives. They loaded the ore into small cars to be hauled to elevators. It closed in 1967 because other techniques were less costly. See Pioneer Mine. Open pit mining involves huge electric shovels loading trucks holding 240 tons of ore. That is less than the fifth of a day's production from the Tower-Soudan mine. See the size of equipment used in "The Taconite Breakthrough".
One economic reason for the reduced Iron Range smaller work force is competition from other sources. Mini-mills produce steel at less cost from scrap metal than the taconite process.
I wonder if a single person in Congress can control forces like these.
The biggest technical reason is productivity. One has only to go to the Tower-Soudan mine and compare it to modern open pit mining. The Tower-Soudan mine employed 475 men working three shifts with picks, shovels, and explosives. They loaded the ore into small cars to be hauled to elevators. It closed in 1967 because other techniques were less costly. See Pioneer Mine. Open pit mining involves huge electric shovels loading trucks holding 240 tons of ore. That is less than the fifth of a day's production from the Tower-Soudan mine. See the size of equipment used in "The Taconite Breakthrough".
One economic reason for the reduced Iron Range smaller work force is competition from other sources. Mini-mills produce steel at less cost from scrap metal than the taconite process.
I wonder if a single person in Congress can control forces like these.
No new taxes means no old fixes
"No new taxes" has become a mantra for many Republican politicians and they have carried out their pledge. However, the result has been that as costs go up many public services and facilities are not being maintained at an appropriate level.
The latest dodge around this is the proposed Minnesota Constitutional amendment to provide a formula to allocate money for roads and transit. The state legislature has been using automobile taxes for other things for years, and rather than raise taxes in other areas, they are using this gimmick to "raise" more money for roads and transit. That is, using the Constitution to do what they should have done politically.
Many who defend "no new taxes" say that government should live within its means, often comparing a government budget to a household budget on a fixed income. Many, including some of the "within its means" people, say government should be run like a business. If this is so, then, like businesses, government should raise prices to meet increased costs, including for the cost of new features that the public wants.
I hope we can have some politicians who are courageous enough to say, "The question is not whether taxes are too high or too low, but are taxes at the appropriate level for the services that people want."
The latest dodge around this is the proposed Minnesota Constitutional amendment to provide a formula to allocate money for roads and transit. The state legislature has been using automobile taxes for other things for years, and rather than raise taxes in other areas, they are using this gimmick to "raise" more money for roads and transit. That is, using the Constitution to do what they should have done politically.
Many who defend "no new taxes" say that government should live within its means, often comparing a government budget to a household budget on a fixed income. Many, including some of the "within its means" people, say government should be run like a business. If this is so, then, like businesses, government should raise prices to meet increased costs, including for the cost of new features that the public wants.
I hope we can have some politicians who are courageous enough to say, "The question is not whether taxes are too high or too low, but are taxes at the appropriate level for the services that people want."
Major party shift coming?
Will a major party shift occur by the next Presidential election? There are signs that it is beginning in Kansas and elsewhere.
This morning's Duluth New Tribune carried a Washington Post story, "Moderates in Kansas decide that they're not in the GOP anymore" (Washington Post, Oct. 19, 2006). I'd call it RINO becomes RINNA (Republican in name only becomes Republican in name not anymore).
Right now the Green Party is a distant third party in many areas. It has won many local and some state offices, but has no representation in Washington. Much of its agenda matches that of the "progressive" wing of the Democratic Party. If moderate Republicans start moving to the Democratic Party, will they, allied with moderate Democrats, take over the Democratic Party. If so, will more left-leaning Democrats start moving to the Green Party? And if this shift occurs on a large scale, will it leave the Republican Party as a minor third party? Will we be saying GOP R.I.P. (Rest in Peace)?
This morning's Duluth New Tribune carried a Washington Post story, "Moderates in Kansas decide that they're not in the GOP anymore" (Washington Post, Oct. 19, 2006). I'd call it RINO becomes RINNA (Republican in name only becomes Republican in name not anymore).
Right now the Green Party is a distant third party in many areas. It has won many local and some state offices, but has no representation in Washington. Much of its agenda matches that of the "progressive" wing of the Democratic Party. If moderate Republicans start moving to the Democratic Party, will they, allied with moderate Democrats, take over the Democratic Party. If so, will more left-leaning Democrats start moving to the Green Party? And if this shift occurs on a large scale, will it leave the Republican Party as a minor third party? Will we be saying GOP R.I.P. (Rest in Peace)?
Friday, October 20, 2006
The invisible hand controls the market?
I just updated my Northland Reader article from 2000 on executive pay, "Talk about Boards with Conflicts of Interest!" I found that many of the links were no longer valid, and so I did another search. One search was
fiorina pay 1999 "69.4 million"
Carly Fiorina was the newly hired CEO of Hewlett-Packard and was one of the highest paid CEOs at the time.
Google only gave me six hits and only one seemed relevant:
The Winner-Steal-All Society and the persistence of the CEO-market mythIt has a great quote:
"[When] it comes to CEO pay, the grasping hand usually trumps the invisible one."
fiorina pay 1999 "69.4 million"
Carly Fiorina was the newly hired CEO of Hewlett-Packard and was one of the highest paid CEOs at the time.
Google only gave me six hits and only one seemed relevant:
The Winner-Steal-All Society and the persistence of the CEO-market mythIt has a great quote:
"[When] it comes to CEO pay, the grasping hand usually trumps the invisible one."
Help make voting private
Secret vote? Not really, anymore
Your actual vote is still secret, at least at most polling places, but politicians are working harder to predict how you will vote. According to the above story in today's Star Tribune of the Twin Cities, politicians are using detailed public and private data to predict how you will vote. If they think you are likely to vote their way, they will phone you, visit you, send brochures to you, and more to make sure you vote on election day.
If you consider this an intrusion on your privacy, you can help make it less profitable for those who practice micro-management of voting. Do whichever of these which suits your personality.
1) If you don't hear a voice when you answer the phone, hang up immediately. You are being called by a machine dialer. You may free a caller up to make the next call, but you are reducing the pool of people they have to talk to.
2) If you didn't hang up fast enough and the caller identifies himself or herself as a solicitor for this or that organization, say something like, "I do not respond to unsolicited calls" and hang up.
3) If you feel opposed to the calling organization, you can possibly get off their list by either asking that you be removed or by saying, "What makes you think I'm interested in your cause?"
4) If you're feeling ornery, you can draw out the conversation as long as possible. This reduces the time the caller will have to talk to other people, reducing the efficiency of this method of getting votes and increase its costs.
You can apply some of these same tactics to pollsters. By not responding you help reduce the accuracy of polls and thus help make a more competitive race. A more competitive race also gives third-party and independent voters a better chance of participating.
Your actual vote is still secret, at least at most polling places, but politicians are working harder to predict how you will vote. According to the above story in today's Star Tribune of the Twin Cities, politicians are using detailed public and private data to predict how you will vote. If they think you are likely to vote their way, they will phone you, visit you, send brochures to you, and more to make sure you vote on election day.
If you consider this an intrusion on your privacy, you can help make it less profitable for those who practice micro-management of voting. Do whichever of these which suits your personality.
1) If you don't hear a voice when you answer the phone, hang up immediately. You are being called by a machine dialer. You may free a caller up to make the next call, but you are reducing the pool of people they have to talk to.
2) If you didn't hang up fast enough and the caller identifies himself or herself as a solicitor for this or that organization, say something like, "I do not respond to unsolicited calls" and hang up.
3) If you feel opposed to the calling organization, you can possibly get off their list by either asking that you be removed or by saying, "What makes you think I'm interested in your cause?"
4) If you're feeling ornery, you can draw out the conversation as long as possible. This reduces the time the caller will have to talk to other people, reducing the efficiency of this method of getting votes and increase its costs.
You can apply some of these same tactics to pollsters. By not responding you help reduce the accuracy of polls and thus help make a more competitive race. A more competitive race also gives third-party and independent voters a better chance of participating.
Property rights vs. property rights
Rod Grams, a candidate for the Minnesota 8th Congressional District seat, has written about and brought up in debates a property rights case that he considers an overreach of Federal authority. He used up almost all of his 600-word essay in today's Duluth News Tribune on this case. As I suspected, the Rapano wetlands case is more complicated than Grams makes it out to be.
The National Association of Counties reports that the Supreme Court decision was 5-4 and five opinions were written.
Amicus curiae briefs in Rapanos’ favor:
Mackinac Center for Public Policy
Attainable Housing Alliance files amicus brief
More details of the case in
Environmental Times, The voice of the environmental industry
Notes and Trends, "Bench and Bar of Minnesota", October 2003
Washington Report, City of Lincoln, Nebraska
This first of these three shows that the Rapanos are not as Grams depicts them. They are developers with many property holdings, and they intended to build a shopping center on a large property that had 48 to 58 acres of wetlands. The second deals more with the legal issues, and if I understand the article correctly, the Federal government's case was upheld by lower courts after the Supreme Court's remand of the case. Note that the Supreme Court did not rule completely in the Rapanos' favor, just that the case was argued in the wrong way. The third is a report on how Congress was dealing with this issue this year. It doesn't paint Jim Oberstar, the incumbent Representative, as such a callous Federal power-grabber as Grams does.
However, I found very little with a search on “rapano” and “wetlands” that was strongly in opposition to the Rapanos’ case. The closest was a blog of an Arkansas canoe club. Even this discussion was not all one-sided.
I’d say that this is mostly a state case. The question is did the Rapanos have all the proper state and local permits. They did not, and they even ignored the advice of their own consultant. There is also what would the impact of their development be on their neigbors. For example, was the wetlands a natural storage area that replenished ground water? If the water is no longer retained, the neighbors wells could have much less water.
There are two issues about property rights here, one clear and one not. The first is just how much authority does the federal government have? If Grams wants to limit authority here, is he willing to limit the authority in the Patriot Act? The second is what are the limits on “property rights”. People can’t start fires in their woods to clear them for farming. Or put another way, your property rights end where my water supply begins.
Disclaimer: I am an advisor and aide to Harry Welty, also a candidate for Minnesota's 8th Congressional District seat.
The National Association of Counties reports that the Supreme Court decision was 5-4 and five opinions were written.
Amicus curiae briefs in Rapanos’ favor:
Mackinac Center for Public Policy
Attainable Housing Alliance files amicus brief
More details of the case in
Environmental Times, The voice of the environmental industry
Notes and Trends, "Bench and Bar of Minnesota", October 2003
Washington Report, City of Lincoln, Nebraska
This first of these three shows that the Rapanos are not as Grams depicts them. They are developers with many property holdings, and they intended to build a shopping center on a large property that had 48 to 58 acres of wetlands. The second deals more with the legal issues, and if I understand the article correctly, the Federal government's case was upheld by lower courts after the Supreme Court's remand of the case. Note that the Supreme Court did not rule completely in the Rapanos' favor, just that the case was argued in the wrong way. The third is a report on how Congress was dealing with this issue this year. It doesn't paint Jim Oberstar, the incumbent Representative, as such a callous Federal power-grabber as Grams does.
However, I found very little with a search on “rapano” and “wetlands” that was strongly in opposition to the Rapanos’ case. The closest was a blog of an Arkansas canoe club. Even this discussion was not all one-sided.
I’d say that this is mostly a state case. The question is did the Rapanos have all the proper state and local permits. They did not, and they even ignored the advice of their own consultant. There is also what would the impact of their development be on their neigbors. For example, was the wetlands a natural storage area that replenished ground water? If the water is no longer retained, the neighbors wells could have much less water.
There are two issues about property rights here, one clear and one not. The first is just how much authority does the federal government have? If Grams wants to limit authority here, is he willing to limit the authority in the Patriot Act? The second is what are the limits on “property rights”. People can’t start fires in their woods to clear them for farming. Or put another way, your property rights end where my water supply begins.
Disclaimer: I am an advisor and aide to Harry Welty, also a candidate for Minnesota's 8th Congressional District seat.
Thursday, October 19, 2006
The future of energy
Harry Welty, congressional candidate, asked me to proofread his answers to a public radio questionnaire for candidates. One of the questions was about a huge goal-gasification plant proposed for northern Minnesota. See MPR: Coal gasification plant: worth the tradeoff?
This plant will produce 1000 megawatts of electricity. The area in which it is being built doesn't need that much power. Are there sufficient transmission lines to distribute that power to other parts of the state? If not, what kind of battles are going to be fought on the location of new lines.
Coal gasification requires steam. Where is the water going to come from and where is it going to go? The plant is proposed in the Hoyt Lakes area. Are these lakes big enough to provide steam for a large plant, drinking water for the area's residents, and recreational water? See Fossil Energy: DOE's Coal Gasification R&D Program. This site also says that gasification "eliminat[es] nearly all air pollutants and potentially greenhouse gas emissions"; but carbon, the chief fuel makes carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas.
Has anybody concerned the national security issues for large power plants? It is much easier for a determined few to take out a large plant than dozens or even hundreds of smaller plants. Remember the havoc wreaked by those who were toppling transmission towers a couple of decades ago.
Will solar and micro-turbines provide for power generation closer to the source? What is the future cost and efficiency of solar panels and batteries. Would a few solar panels and a couple of batteries provide evening lights and cooking power for a house? Even if the house got most of its electricity from the grid, would the future cost be low enough that neighborhoods would not go dark when a transformer blows or a storm brings down lines?
I can't do all the research I would like at the moment, but consider these statements:
“By 2030 the cost [of solar generation] will be comparable to electricity produced by a nuclear power plant.”
“Fossil fuel resources will be totally out by then.”
- Solar costs halved by 2010? Sharp thinks so, MSNBC, Aug. 31, 2006
I think this may be the basis of my next article for the Reader Weekly.
This plant will produce 1000 megawatts of electricity. The area in which it is being built doesn't need that much power. Are there sufficient transmission lines to distribute that power to other parts of the state? If not, what kind of battles are going to be fought on the location of new lines.
Coal gasification requires steam. Where is the water going to come from and where is it going to go? The plant is proposed in the Hoyt Lakes area. Are these lakes big enough to provide steam for a large plant, drinking water for the area's residents, and recreational water? See Fossil Energy: DOE's Coal Gasification R&D Program. This site also says that gasification "eliminat[es] nearly all air pollutants and potentially greenhouse gas emissions"; but carbon, the chief fuel makes carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas.
Has anybody concerned the national security issues for large power plants? It is much easier for a determined few to take out a large plant than dozens or even hundreds of smaller plants. Remember the havoc wreaked by those who were toppling transmission towers a couple of decades ago.
Will solar and micro-turbines provide for power generation closer to the source? What is the future cost and efficiency of solar panels and batteries. Would a few solar panels and a couple of batteries provide evening lights and cooking power for a house? Even if the house got most of its electricity from the grid, would the future cost be low enough that neighborhoods would not go dark when a transformer blows or a storm brings down lines?
I can't do all the research I would like at the moment, but consider these statements:
“By 2030 the cost [of solar generation] will be comparable to electricity produced by a nuclear power plant.”
“Fossil fuel resources will be totally out by then.”
- Solar costs halved by 2010? Sharp thinks so, MSNBC, Aug. 31, 2006
I think this may be the basis of my next article for the Reader Weekly.
Tuesday, October 17, 2006
Foxes guarding the chicken coop (CEOs setting own salaries)
William McGuire, CEO of UnitedHealth, is the latest to get caught with his hand in the cookie jar. No wonder health costs are so high.
I wrote about the conflict of interest six years ago; I said that all the interlocking directorships of CEOs serving on each other boards does not give them an unbiased view toward executive compensation. You scratch my back; I'll scratch yours.
I wrote about the conflict of interest six years ago; I said that all the interlocking directorships of CEOs serving on each other boards does not give them an unbiased view toward executive compensation. You scratch my back; I'll scratch yours.
Education or training
My friend Don pointed out that much of what passes for education is really training. Are doctors and dentist educated or trained in their respective schools? Are engineers, musicians, and artists educated or trained? Many other skills that require higher education for employment are more learning best practice than learning how to create something new.
Monday, October 16, 2006
Education - a boon or a boondoggle?
The Atlantic, Nov. 2006, has an opinion piece, "A Matter of Degrees" which argues that a college education is not all that beneficial. One thing that is skewing the statistics on wages is that some college graduates' salaries are increasing dramatically, giving the idea that all college graduates' salaries are much better than non-graduates' salaries. A graduate with a degree in materials science may be earning quite a lot, but a Ph.D in medieval history may be earning less than an auto mechanic with a two-year degree.
Another problem is that employers are requiring more formal education for jobs that had traditionally been learned on the job. For example, hotels used to promote staff through the ranks with in-house training; now some chains require a four-year degree in hotel management.
Over-specialization of job requirements also limits the supply of available workers, thus driving up the cost. See my article "Tech staff shortage", a different perspective on the so-called tech staff shortage that was claimed during the .com boom.
While reading about the need for long-range goals of students to meet these new requirements, I thought about how we try to stimulate a result with tests rather than work from the beginning with encouraging interest in general. For example, rather than test for reading ability with teachers teaching to the test, why don't we spend more effort encouraging students to read in the first place?
I sent the following letter to the Duluth News Tribune on July 24, 2005. I do not remember if it was published.
Another problem is that employers are requiring more formal education for jobs that had traditionally been learned on the job. For example, hotels used to promote staff through the ranks with in-house training; now some chains require a four-year degree in hotel management.
Over-specialization of job requirements also limits the supply of available workers, thus driving up the cost. See my article "Tech staff shortage", a different perspective on the so-called tech staff shortage that was claimed during the .com boom.
While reading about the need for long-range goals of students to meet these new requirements, I thought about how we try to stimulate a result with tests rather than work from the beginning with encouraging interest in general. For example, rather than test for reading ability with teachers teaching to the test, why don't we spend more effort encouraging students to read in the first place?
I sent the following letter to the Duluth News Tribune on July 24, 2005. I do not remember if it was published.
Which is more responsible for improvement in reading scores – President George W. Bush and his No Child Left Behind Act or J. K. Rowling and her “Harry Potter” series? Often it is the indirect influence that works better than the direct action. I would say engaging literature children want to read improves reading ability far more than testing of reading ability. If such is true, then well-stocked school and public libraries would improve reading far more than merit pay, mandated tests, and a whole array of top-down mandates.
Will the last Iraqi turn out the lights?
I wrote the title before I remembered the popular Iraqi TV show, broadcast from outside Iraq of course. It is "Hurry Up, He's Dead", a break-up of the Arabic word for "The Government".
I also came across "The Last Iraqi Insurgency", New York Times, April 18, 2004, a recap of the British occcupation of Iraq starting in 1920. The last British soldier left in 1955.
I thought about this entry while reading "Carriers of Conflict" in the November issue of The Atlantic (sorry, only a preview is available to non-subscribers). However, the accompanying map is available.
Over 700,000 Iraqis have left Iraq for Jordan, 450,000 for Syria, and 54,000 for Iran. That's out of a CIA 2006 estimate of over 27 million population. What would we think if over 12 million U.S. citizens fled to Canada or Mexico?
But these refugees are not the stereotypical mother and child. They include many who are willing and able to fight. They will not only make forays back into Iraq, but they take over camps and other refugee settlements, pushing aside traditional tribal leaders. They also destablize the host countries. The author compares the Iraqi exodus to the Palestinian diaspora. Consider what happened in Lebanon and Jordan.
I think we might call the Iraq War "Bushdora's Box". "Those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it." - George Santayana.
I also came across "The Last Iraqi Insurgency", New York Times, April 18, 2004, a recap of the British occcupation of Iraq starting in 1920. The last British soldier left in 1955.
I thought about this entry while reading "Carriers of Conflict" in the November issue of The Atlantic (sorry, only a preview is available to non-subscribers). However, the accompanying map is available.
Over 700,000 Iraqis have left Iraq for Jordan, 450,000 for Syria, and 54,000 for Iran. That's out of a CIA 2006 estimate of over 27 million population. What would we think if over 12 million U.S. citizens fled to Canada or Mexico?
But these refugees are not the stereotypical mother and child. They include many who are willing and able to fight. They will not only make forays back into Iraq, but they take over camps and other refugee settlements, pushing aside traditional tribal leaders. They also destablize the host countries. The author compares the Iraqi exodus to the Palestinian diaspora. Consider what happened in Lebanon and Jordan.
I think we might call the Iraq War "Bushdora's Box". "Those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it." - George Santayana.
Sunday, October 15, 2006
Equal opportunity vandalism
A few have written to the Duluth News Tribune that their lawn signs for Republican or conservative candidates have been stolen or damaged. These letter writers charge that it is Democrats or liberals who steal or damage signs.
A smaller number have written to state that their lawn signs for Democratic or liberal candidates have also been damaged or stolen. These writers point out that the vandals are probably apolitical.
This past week I had my Welty sign stolen. Harry Welty is a moderate, ex-Republican who is running for Congress. There were also a beer can and fast food containers on the boulevard or sidewalk.
I think the sign stealers are the jerks that park and picnic outside their own neighborhoods. They don't care about littering and they think their vandalism is "only having fun".
A smaller number have written to state that their lawn signs for Democratic or liberal candidates have also been damaged or stolen. These writers point out that the vandals are probably apolitical.
This past week I had my Welty sign stolen. Harry Welty is a moderate, ex-Republican who is running for Congress. There were also a beer can and fast food containers on the boulevard or sidewalk.
I think the sign stealers are the jerks that park and picnic outside their own neighborhoods. They don't care about littering and they think their vandalism is "only having fun".
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)