Showing posts with label free markets. Show all posts
Showing posts with label free markets. Show all posts

Sunday, May 12, 2013

Opposition to the EPA is just a GOP plot to dismantle public education

Mercury, lead, and several other pollutants are known for reducing cognitive function. If these pollutants are kept at high levels, then many children will not perform well in school. If many children don't perform well, it will demonstrate that public schools are failing. Thus, private interests, which always do "better" will take over. Of course, they can reject those children adversely affected by pollutants.

I posted the above as a comment to "The Latest G.O.P. Temper Tantrum", Robert B. Semple, Jr., New York Times, 2013-05-09.  Temper tantrum is the description Semple gave the walkout by some G.O.P. Senators from the hearings for the confirmation of Gina McCarthy as the head of the EPA.  See also "Lead and 'failing' schools".

E. Nowak of Illinois responded to my comment with

"And the closer people live to factories, the more toxins they breath in. The rich, always live far, far away from the industrial centers."

But we don't even have to live close to factories to be introduced to toxins.  What are all the pesticides used in agriculture doing to us.  What are the neoniconitides used to "kill aphids and other crop-destroying insects" doing to us?  These are nerve poisons that disrupt neural activity.  They are put into seeds and "become incorporated in the tissues of the adult plant".  If we eat these plants what's to guarantee that the neurotoxins won't be affecting us?  See "Honeybee die-off brings 'Silent Spring' back to mind", William Souder, Star Tribune, 2013-05-12.  In other words, are these neurotoxins affecting the performance of school children?

I'm sorry if you think I'm a scold about free markets and Adam Smith's "invisible hand", but we really have to hold to account those who corrupt both ideas to hide their own self-interest against the public good.  Please tell your friends about

"The Invisible Adam Smith" and "Humpty Dumpty and Free Markets".

Friday, December 07, 2012

Free markets and governments

"Alex Marshall, a journalist and senior fellow at the Regional Plan Association, has written two books on the topic of cities: "How Cities Work: Suburbs, Sprawl and The Roads Not Taken" and "Beneath the Metropolis: The Secret Lives of Cities." He also lectures on urbanism and teaches courses on infrastructure.

"His newest book, released this fall, is a departure—but not as radical of one as it might first appear. "The Surprising Design of Market Economies" debunks the notion that free markets are 'natural.'"

From "What Jane Jacobs Got Wrong About Urban Economies", Allison Arieff, TheAtlanticCities, 2012-12-05.

Marshall's final comment is "We are a democracy and we ought to act like it."

Friday, November 09, 2012

"Free marketers" once again prevent free markets

Well, Proposition 37, requiring labeling of GMO foods in California, was defeated by the overwhelming resources of self-interested corporations.  Free markets mean all necessary information.  By hiding the contents of their products, agribusinesses are denying free markets to the consumer.  See "Letter about GMO foods".

You might also consider the words of Adam Smith in "Wealth of Nations":

"The proposal of any new law or regulation of commerce which comes from this order, ought always to be listened to with great precaution, and ought never to be adopted till after having been long and carefully examined, not only with the most scrupulous, but with the most suspicious attention. It comes from an order of men, whose interest is never exactly the same with that of the public, who have generally an interest to deceive and even to oppress the public, and who accordingly have, upon many occasions, both deceived and oppressed it." - pages 142-143

I included the above in "The Invisible Adam Smith".

I hope you're not allergic to any foods that have been spliced into other foods.

Monday, August 27, 2012

Humpty Dumpty and Free Markets

The Coffee Party on Facebook had a link to a CNN interview of Christine O'Donnell by Soledad O'Brien.  O'Donnell claims the Obama has made Marxist remarks.  O'Brien did call her on using the term Marxist but didn't really follow through.  Many respondents to the Coffee Party page were disappointed that O'Brien didn't press for specifics.

One commenter mentioned that the Wealth of Nations wasn't published when the Declaration of Indendence was written, and so the signers couldn't include Adam Smith's thoughts.

I added the following to the comments:

Words! Words!  As Humpty Dumpty said in Lewis Carroll's "Through the Looking Glass": 'When I use a word,' Humpty Dumpty said, in rather a scornful tone, 'it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.'

Worse than the misuse of the words "Marxism" and "Socialism" is the misuse of the word "Free Market".

The classical definition of a free market is:

1. Many buyers and sellers
2. Buyers and sellers are free to enter and leave the market at any time.
3. Buyers and sellers have all the information they need to make a satisfactory transaction.
4. All the costs are covered in the transaction, that is, no externalities.

Interestingly, it is "free marketers" who don't want true free markets.

We have more and more consolidations into larger and larger corporations.

Are you free to leave the health care market when your child is sick?

GMO producers and others don't want buyers to know what's in their products.

Who is covering the costs of pollution and nuclear waste?

Adam Smith's "Wealth of Nations" was first published in 1776.  Maybe the signers of the Declaration of Independence hadn't received copies yet, but I'm sure that many of the signers of the Constitution had read it by 1787.

Those who love to quote the "invisible hand" should read the other 500+ pages, including "When the regulation, therefore, is in favour of the workmen, it is always just and equitable; but it is sometimes
otherwise when in favour of the masters."

Wednesday, August 01, 2012

GMO producers don't want free markets

Susan K. Finston has written an op-ed piece on GMO products and labeling in many places, including the Fresno Bee, "FDA shouldn't order costly GMO labels".  I read it in the Duluth News Tribune was part of one the DNT's Pro and Con pairings.  See https://secure.forumcomm.com/?publisher_ID=36&article_id=236256.  It was published in many newspapers across the country on 2012-07-07.  The DNT published only two letters on her article, both in opposition.  One was mine that was titled by the editor as "Lack of information spells doom for free markets – and possibly people".  See https://secure.forumcomm.com/?publisher_ID=36&article_id=237319.  The text is :

Free markets are disappearing, and it is free-market proponents who are taking them away.

The classic definition of a free market is:
Many buyers and many sellers.
Both buyers and sellers are free to enter and leave the market.
Both buyers and sellers have all the information they need to make an advantageous transaction.
All costs are covered in the transaction; that is, there are no externalities.

In this letter I want to cover a third point: all the information needed. This was ignored by Susan K. Finston in her Pro/Con commentary, “FDA shouldn’t order costly GMO labels just to satisfy scientific illiterates,” which was published in the News Tribune on July 7.

The top story on an online search for “GMO deaths” is about sudden cattle deaths at a small ranch in Texas. However, it was hybrid grass that produced cyanide after a couple of drought years that caused the deaths.  If a hybrid grass can do this, how do we know that a GMO grass won’t do the same?

As to be expected, most of the hits led to “sensationalist” sites, those with a cause; they only repeated stories from elsewhere. I added, “Union of Concerned Scientists” to my search and found a much more credible report: “Environmental Effects of Genetically Modified Food Crops — Recent Experiences,” by Margaret Mellon and Jane Rissler, writing for the Union of Concerned Scientists website.

“No major human health problems have emerged in connection with genetically modified food products,” Mellon and Rissler reported. But a company put a Brazil nut gene into soybeans to increase the latter’s nutritional quality.  Experiments showed that people allergic to Brazil nuts were also allergic to the altered soybeans.

Some allergic reactions are fatal. Would you rather eat foods you know don’t give you a reaction? Or would you like being surprised by a fatal ingredient? Labeling is important!

Thursday, July 26, 2012

Quote of the day: Corporations are governments, not persons

I am slowly working my way through George Lakoff's "Whose Freedom? The Battle over America's Most Important Idea".  He looks at how and why conservatives and progressive frame the issues.  A section that really hit home on the mythical framing of the "free market" was "Corporations are governments, not persons" under the section "The Truths Hidden by the Economic Liberty Myth".

You can find the section here as well as some reviews.

Tuesday, April 03, 2012

"Socialism" and "free markets", an observation

The ideologues of "socialism" think that taking away the benefits of the few will benefit the many.

The ideologues of "free markets" think the benefits of the few will benefit the many.

In either case, only the ideologues benefit and the many get the crumbs.

Tuesday, February 07, 2012

Free markets, unions, and Adam Smith yet again

I was published again, this time in the Star Tribune on the selective reading by many of Adam Smith's "Wealth of Nations". I also proposed a standardized test for legislators. See http://www.startribune.com/opinion/letters/138816234.html.



Friday, January 20, 2012

Flea markets are the only true free markets, sort of

Many are calling for free markets without any idea of what free markets really are. Free markets are not large corporations unencumbered by government regulation.

Flea markets and farmers' markets are better approximations of true free markets. Why is this?

A flea market has many buyers and sellers, although some sellers might think there are not enough buyers.

Buyers and sellers are free to enter and leave the flea market. Of course, sellers may have to apply for limited space and it will take a bit of time to pack up to leave the flea market.

Buyers and sellers have all the information they need to make a decision to buy or sell. The buyers can pick up the goods and even give them a small test. Sellers accepting only cash generally can assume the bills are good.

There are few externalities from a flea market. There could be lots of trash to be picked up. Some products sold may be defective and injure somebody.

Can you think of any other economic activity that even gets close to the free market standard set by flea markets and farmers' markets?

See also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_market



Friday, December 02, 2011

Comment on "job creators"

I posted the following as a comment to the Coffee Party's Facebook posting of "7 Ways to Support the Real Job Creators".
I highly recommend slogging through the 1000+ pages of 18th Century English that are Adam Smith's "Wealth of Nations".

Would you believe that he is more sympathetic to the workmen than the masters? That he thinks banks should be regulated? That taxes are necessary? That we have to co-operate with and assist one another? That talents come from our experiences? That he doesn't believe in giving 110% to employers? That the rich get rich at the expense of the poor? That governments are needed to enforce contract law? That merchants complain that high wages affect the economy but say nothing of how high profits affect the economy? That honorable professions are underpaid? That regulations are needed to prevent abuse? That he doesn't think much of corporations controlling government? That corporations are not concerned with the public interest? That although he complained it was illegal for workers to unite to raise wages but legal for masters to unite to keep wages down, he didn't think much of labor unions? But that regulations in favor of workers were just but those in favor of the masters were unjust?

Those are only some of the comments with which I annotated the first 150 pages of my Project Gutenberg copy of "Wealth of Nations".



Sunday, September 18, 2011

If you believe in unfettered free markets…

I have some tulip bulbs for you.

If you believe in unfettered free markets, I have some mortgages to sell you. Trust me, they are all low risk.

If you believe in unfettered free markets, I plan to buy the lot next to your house and start a junk yard.

If you believe in unfettered free markets, I plan to buy the lot on the other side of your house and start raising pigs.

You say I can't do these. I can if I pay your neighbors enough for their houses and don't tell them my intent.

You say there are laws against my doing these things in residential neighborhoods. I thought you were for unfettered free markets. These laws are fetters on the free markets. Besides, if I make enough contributions to candidates that see things my way, then they'll change the laws in my favor.

Preposterous, you say. Not at all. It's happening with big corporations selling risky investments without giving you complete information (complete information being a requirement for a free market), putting up unsightly commercial buildings in residential neighborhoods, polluting our air and water, and making exorbitant contributions to candidates, parties, and "right"-minded think tanks.

Sunday, July 17, 2011

You are being manipulated, lied to, and bamboozled! Here's how

So you think the U.S. has the best health care system in the world, that free enterprise made this country great and any government intervention stifles free enterprise, and you think that we don't have global warming but maybe climate change, then you are being manipulated, lied to, and bamboozled by the spin doctors of large corporations.  They are putting out big bucks in advertising to get us to see things their way and big bucks in campaign contributions and lobbying to have governments do things their way.  Forget, "We the People".

The writers of the U. S. Constitution used "people" in the sense of communities.  When they meant individuals they used "persons" or "citizens".  Large corporations don't want communities, whether they are unions, co-operatives, or any other group where people come together for their common economic interest.  They want isolated individuals to whom they can target their messages.

I've long suspected that corporate interests aren't my interests, or even many others interests, but I've become strongly aware of this after reading three books on corporate manipulation of us and our elected officials.

The first was "Deadly Spin" by Wendell Potter on how the health insurance companies work to minimize their payouts and maximize their profits, even if it gives bad health outcomes to their customers.  I have already written about this book; see "Benefits - Getting mad at the wrong people?"

The second is "23 Things They Don't Tell You about Capitalism" by Ha-Joon Chang.  Chang's first Thing is "There is no such thing as a free market", that is individuals acting in their own best interest.  This free market idea simplifies individuals into economic entities without complex personalities.

The third is "Life, Inc., How the World Became a Corporation and How to Take it Back" by Douglas Rushkoff.  His starting point is how limited liability corporations started and what they enabled.  Like any good idea, this has morphed into a monster that "The People" can't control.

If you can stomach reading about the manipulations, you might find these books very informative and fascinating.  If you're reading this blog, you probably see the world as a more complex place than the spin doctors would have us believe.  These books might give you more information to counter the spin doctors.  If you think the world is relatively simple, then please read these books before you vote again.

Tuesday, June 14, 2011

Tea Party critique published

I submitted a "Local View" on the Tea Party to the Duluth News Tribune.  It was published today with the title "Tea Party positions misses today's complexities".  You can find it for a week or so at http://www.duluthnewstribune.com/event/tag/group/Opinion/tag/Local%20view/

The opinion page editor, Chuck Frederick, changed almost every line, as his wont.  Fortunately, his sends his revisions of my Local Views to me before publication.  It was a good thing because he added a word that changed the meaning of one point.  I pointed it out and he printed it with my correction.

Thanks to the four people who said they liked it.

Essentially I wrote that the Tea Party Patriots' fiscal responsibility can be irresponsible, their limited constitutional government cannot be determined by the "intent" of the writers, and their free markets haven't existed since the railroads began.

One question readers may have in reading "the last great Republican President, Abraham Lincoln" is who do I consider the last great Democratic President.  I thought about it for five minutes and came up with Thomas Jefferson, who was then called a Democratic-Republican.

Wednesday, April 27, 2011

And the "Free Market" Party keeps opposing free markets

The Democrats are often wishy-washy on issues and often beholden to corporate interests, but the Republicans take the blue ribbon on hypocrisy.

The Republicans claim they are for free markets, but an economist's definition of a free market and the Republicans' definition of a free market are polar opposites.

The economist's definition of a free market includes that both buyer and seller should have all the information they need to make a decision.

The Republic's definition is that big corporations should be free to do what they want, including hiding or obfuscating information buyers need to make a decision.

A case in point is the opposition to Elizabeth Warren to head up the Consumer Financial Protection Agency.  She is called "controversial", but what is controversial about true free markets in:

“We’re trying to make the price clear, the risk clear, and make it easy to compare products,” Warren said. “If banks can’t build a business model without fooling people about the price, or hiding the risks, or obfuscating the products so nobody can make any direct comparisons, they’ve got a problem.”

This quote is from "Warren tells the controversial truth", Al Lewis, MarketWatch, 2011-04-22.

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Why is nuclear energy so popular among some politicians?

Because it is anti-free market.

Anti-free market?  How can that be?  We have legislatures dominated by free-market proponents.

How many large companies stand to benefit from nuclear power?  You don't need to use more than one hand to count them.

How many medium and small companies benefit from wind and solar?  Lots and lots.

A free market has many buyers and many sellers.  If you have a few sellers, the market is not so free.

It is the interest of ever-larger corporations to become even larger.  Larger corporations give larger donations.

Nuclear power companies probably have given some very large political donations.

Can the wind energy market give such large donations?

Now you know why the push for nuclear energy.

Tuesday, March 01, 2011

Free markets and capitalism – their supporters don't want them!

Disclaimer: We own shares in some companies and mutual funds.  In our retirement we will depend more and more on dividends and interest.  However, we don't feel compelled to hide the warts in the system.

We read many complaints that the U.S. is becoming socialist and turning against free markets and capitalism.  Well, we are seeing many efforts to erode free markets and capitalism, but these efforts are being made most strongly by those who proclaim them.

The classical definition of a free market is one with many buyers and many sellers and with both buyer and seller having all the information they need to make a decision.  Oh, also, either the buyer or seller should be free to enter or leave the market.

We see many moves to reduce the number of sellers as companies gobble up their competitors.  We also see some moves to reduce the number of buyers - Wal-Mart has become the sole buyer for many suppliers.

Many large corporations fight efforts to give buyers important information to make a good decision.  The tobacco companies denying their products caused harm is one of the more egregious distortions of important information.  Agribusiness companies don't want foods labelled as genetically modified.  Many large dairy companies don't want competitors products labeled BGH-free (bovine growth hormone).  Telecommunication companies make it difficult to know the exact cost of their services before a customer makes a purchase.  How come the billing computers know exactly what a customer should pay but the sales computers supposedly don't have that information?

Freedom to enter and leave the market exists in varying degrees.  There are certainly many products we can choose to buy or not buy.  Suppliers with a single buyer can stop selling to that buyer, but they will have a lot of work to replace that buyer.

Capitalism - ah, a lovely concept when it started.  Some people got together and pooled their money to form a company, each getting shares proportional to their contribution.  Then markets developed to buy and sell those shares as owners wanted to reallocate their investments.  All well and good.  If Smith wanted to sell his shares in XYZ to buy a house and Jones was glad to buy XYZ shares because he missed out when they were issued, that's all above board.

I won't get into day-trading versus investing or all the derivatives that Wall Street thinks up.  This is almost all smoke and mirrors and a long, long way from capitalism.

As economies grew, so did the companies originally financed with stock.  But as they grew, the shareholders became more and more distant from the operation of the company.  They had to hire executives and board members to run the company.  All well and good.  But with all the buying and selling of shares, the shareholders had little interest in the company other than it grew and turned a profit.  Few had any interest in the day-to-day running of the company.

As time went on, the board members nominated themselves for successive terms, without any competition.  Shareholders could either accept them or withhold their votes; the boards made any mechanisms to offer a different slate extremely difficult.  To make matters worse, many of the shares were owned by mutual funds and other institutions; in general, the operators of these institutions exercised their "fiduciary responsibility" and voted with the board.

In many democratic countries, the boards lobbied their friends in governments to put up various hindrances to any shareholder control beyond the above yes or no votes.

These board members grant their appointed executives shares in the company for their "performance" and grant themselves the same.  In other words, they are giving themselves more and more of the company and more and more of the votes.  The board members often get over $100,000 per year for showing up for six meetings.  Nice work if you can get it.

Many define this whole process as capitalism and as a great good.  I call it capturism; the few have captured control of a company to run as they see fit.  At least, unlike many oligarchies, they don't throw dissidents in jail.